# Open PEN, PME and EVs — the Section 722 anchor

> On a **PME (TN-C-S)** supply the combined neutral-and-earth (PEN) conductor can break in the network. If it does, exposed metalwork can rise toward live potential — a serious touch-voltage hazard. Because an electric vehicle is large, often outdoors and touched by a person standing on the ground, BS 7671 **§722.411.4.1** says you must **not** simply rely on the distributor's PME earth for the EV unless one of a short list of **open-PEN protective measures** is applied. That same rule is the reason the **floating-V2L-on-PME** earthing question is contested: it is exactly the open-PEN problem in reverse, and it must be designed and proven by test by a competent person — the vehicle manufacturer does not sanction this use.

**Safety frame.** This is education, not an instruction to carry out work. Work connecting V2L equipment to fixed wiring is safety-critical and may be notifiable under Part P. It must be designed, installed, inspected and tested by a competent person to the current edition of BS 7671. Vehicle manufacturers generally do not sanction back-feeding fixed wiring from V2L outlets; follow manufacturer instructions.

## In short

- On a **PME (TN-C-S)** supply, the neutral and earth share one combined PEN conductor up to the cut-out — and if that PEN breaks, metalwork can rise toward line voltage.
- BS 7671 **§722.411.4.1** says a PME earth must **not** be relied on for an EV unless a **listed open-PEN protective measure** is applied.
- The standard lists explicit **open-PEN protective measures** (described by category, not reproduced): broadly a TT electrode for the EV circuit, an open-PEN disconnection device (≈70 V threshold), a voltage-limiting device, or an equivalent — A4:2026 removed the former 'not reasonably practicable' exception. Verified against the licensed text (2026-07-09); exact limits and device conditions live in the licensed standard and the IET CoP.
- This is the rule that drives the V2L earthing decision: a separate outbuilding is made **TT** on its own electrode; indoors you keep the single PME/MET earth and use an **isolation transformer**.
- Contested ground: floating-V2L-on-PME must be **designed and proven by test by a competent person**. The vehicle manufacturer does not sanction back-feeding fixed wiring from a V2L outlet.

**Where this stops:** This explains the open-PEN hazard and what the standard requires. It is not a wiring recipe — the protective measure, its design, installation and testing are for a competent person.

## The short answer

On a **PME (TN-C-S)** supply, neutral and earth share one **combined PEN conductor** in the network up to your cut-out. If that PEN conductor breaks (an 'open PEN'), the load current looks for another way home — through your earthing and bonding, through earthed metalwork, and potentially through a person. Exposed metal can rise toward line voltage. An electric vehicle is a large, often outdoor lump of earthed metal that people touch while standing on the ground, so it is squarely in scope of this hazard. That is why **BS 7671 §722.411.4.1** says you must **not** simply rely on the distributor's PME earth for an EV unless you apply one of a short list of **open-PEN protective measures**.

> **Why this page is the anchor** — Every V2L earthing decision on this site — TT outbuilding, indoor isolation transformer, switched neutral-earth bond — traces back to this one rule. Read this page to understand *why* those arrangements exist; read the cornerstone and the method pages for *how* a competent person builds them.

## What 'open PEN' means, plainly {#open-pen-pme}

In a PME (Protective Multiple Earthing) arrangement, the distributor combines neutral and protective earth into one conductor — the PEN — and earths it at multiple points along the network. At your property the PEN splits into a separate neutral and an earth at the supply terminal. The scheme is safe **while the PEN is intact**. If the PEN fails somewhere upstream, your installation's neutral current has to return another way. Because your earth and neutral were joined at the cut-out, that return current now flows in the earthing and bonding system, lifting earthed metalwork — pipes, the car body, an EV's exposed-conductive-parts — toward live potential. Nothing inside your installation has 'gone wrong'; the danger is imported from a fault in the network.

**Figure: Open-PEN hazard on a PME supply.** If the combined PEN conductor breaks on a PME supply, load current returns through the earth/bonding path and lifts exposed metalwork toward live potential — a touch-voltage hazard.

_On a PME (TN-C-S) supply the line (L) stays live while the combined protective-and-neutral (PEN) conductor is shown broken upstream. With the PEN open, the neutral return current has to find another path — through the installation's earthing and bonding — which raises exposed metalwork and a connected EV body toward line voltage, creating a touch-voltage shock hazard. This is why BS 7671 §722.411.4.1 restricts relying on a PME earth for an EV and requires a listed open-PEN protective measure._

> **§722** (BS 7671, confidence: inference) — Electric vehicle charging installations is the special-location section. A car's standalone V2L socket feeding portable loads sits outside the fixed installation — but the moment that output is wired into the consumer unit it becomes fixed-wiring work, and §722's open-PEN/PME rules are in play. _Reference only; standard text not reproduced._

## What §722.411.4.1 actually requires

The clause does not ban PME outright. It says a PME earthing facility **must not be relied on** for the EV **unless** one of the explicit open-PEN protective measures is applied. Without reproducing the standard's list, those measures are, by category: a **dedicated earth electrode** giving the EV circuit a TT arrangement, an **open-PEN disconnection device** (operating around a 70 V threshold), a **voltage-limiting device**, or an equivalent measure — and under **A4:2026 the former 'not reasonably practicable' exception is gone**, so one of the routes must actually be applied (verified against the licensed text, 2026-07-09). The exact measures, their limits and the conditions on any disconnecting device are set out in the licensed BS 7671 §722.411.4.1 and interpreted in the IET Code of Practice — consult those, not a web paraphrase, when selecting one.

> **§722.411.4.1** (BS 7671, confidence: inference) — A PME facility must not be relied on for an EV unless one of the listed open-PEN protective measures is applied; and a device used for the purpose must not re-close onto the hazard — it must not restore the dangerous connection automatically once it has tripped on an open PEN. _Reference only; standard text not reproduced._

> **The 'no re-close onto the hazard' point is easy to miss** — A protective device here must not behave like a self-resetting auto-changeover that quietly re-energises the dangerous path once conditions look normal again. If it trips on an open PEN, it must stay safe. This is a design-and-test requirement, not a setting you tick.

## How the IET Code of Practice frames it

The IET **Code of Practice for EV Charging Equipment Installation (5th edition, 2023)** is the EV-specific companion to BS 7671. Its **Section 10 — 'Vehicle as Storage'** covers vehicle-to-home and island-mode operation, including earthing on a PME supply and the use of **open-PEN detection devices**. The 5th edition is understood to reflect a **narrowing of the PME open-PEN workaround** at §722.411.4.1 — that is, fewer or more tightly-bounded ways to lean on PME than installers once assumed.

> **Confidence: inference** — The IET CoP (5th ed., Section 10) reflects a narrowing of the §722.411.4.1 PME open-PEN workaround. (This is a framing inference from the CoP card, not a precise indent claim. The exact indent lettering of the §722.411.4.1 list, and which indent was narrowed or removed, is amendment-dependent and shifts between BS 7671 versions. Treat it as 'the easy PME route has tightened — confirm the current indents against the licensed standard', never as a specific 'indent (i) was deleted'.)

> **Section 10** (IET CoP EV Charging (5th ed.), confidence: inference) — 'Vehicle as Storage' — earthing where the vehicle acts as storage on a PME supply, and open-PEN detection devices. The contested floating-earth-on-PME approach must be designed and proven by test. The CoP is BS 7671:2018+A2:2022-aligned; an A4:2026-aligned EV CoP is not yet published. _Reference only; standard text not reproduced._

## Why this drives the V2L earthing decision

A car's V2L output is, on the units we have looked at, **floating** — it has no internal neutral-earth bond, so on its own it offers no earth reference at all. The instinct is to borrow the house's PME earth. But that is precisely what §722.411.4.1 warns against: importing the PME earth onto the V2L island re-imports the open-PEN hazard. So the same rule that restricts relying on PME for *charging* an EV also shapes how you earth an EV used as a *source*. The two standard responses on this site both follow directly from it:

- **Separate outbuilding → make it TT.** Drive a local earth electrode, keep all circuit protective conductors continuous to the outbuilding earth bar, do not export the dwelling's PME earth, and make the single V2L neutral-earth bond only when on V2L. The local electrode is the 'additional earth' answer to the open-PEN problem — provided no metal pipe, structure or cable armour bridges the two earth systems.
- **Inside the dwelling → isolation transformer.** You cannot TT a single indoor sub-board (simultaneous-reach hazard with the rest of the PME installation), so you keep the one PME/MET earth and use an isolation transformer to galvanically separate the floating output, with a single neutral-earth bond on the transformer secondary.

**Figure: V2L / PME changeover earthing circuit.** On a PME (TN-C-S) supply the V2L island gets its own earth reference — the CPC stays continuous, the neutral-earth bond is switched in only on V2L, and a local electrode provides the earth.

_The diagram shows two sources feeding an essential board through a changeover. From the grid, line (L) and neutral (N) arrive at the changeover; the circuit protective conductor (E/CPC) runs continuously to the board and earth bar and is never switched. From the V2L source, L and N arrive at the other side of the changeover. A neutral-earth (N–E) bond is made only when the board is on V2L, providing the floating output its single earth reference. A local earth electrode connects to the earth bar. The point: every source has exactly one neutral-earth reference, and the protective conductor is continuous in both switch states._

> **§551.4.3.2.1** (BS 7671, confidence: inference) — A source supplying in island mode or as a switched alternative needs an independent means of earthing and must not rely solely on the distributor's earth. This is §722.411.4.1's open-PEN concern seen from the source side: the island cannot lean on a PME earth that might be open or disconnected. _Reference only; standard text not reproduced._

> **Contested ground — the standing wrapper** — Floating-V2L-on-PME is a contested earthing arrangement. It is only ever valid when designed and proven by test by a competent person, and the vehicle manufacturer does not sanction back-feeding fixed wiring from a V2L outlet. Nothing on this page is a settled recipe; it explains the rule that any competent design must satisfy.

## What this page does NOT claim

> **Confidence: verified** — A4:2026 revised §722.411.4.1: the former 'not reasonably practicable' exception is removed, leaving the explicit protective-measure routes described above. (Verified against the licensed BS 7671:2018+A4:2026 text with IET GN3 / On-Site Guide 9th ed by the site's competent-person reviewer (2026-07-09). Cited by reference and category only; the standard's text is not reproduced.)

> **Not confirmed (safety-critical):** We do NOT pin the exact indent lettering of the §722.411.4.1 list, nor state which indent the IET CoP narrowed. That lettering is amendment-dependent — confirm the current indents against the licensed BS 7671 before relying on a specific one.

### How this is made and proven compliant

**What governs it:** BS 7671 §722.411.4.1 — PME must not be relied on for an EV unless a listed open-PEN protective measure is applied; BS 7671 §551.4.3.2.1 — independent means of earthing for island / switched-alternative operation; IET Code of Practice for EV Charging Equipment Installation, 5th ed., Section 10 ('Vehicle as Storage') — interprets §722 for vehicle-to-home use (A2:2022-aligned)

**Who may do it:** Selecting and proving an open-PEN protective measure, and the earthing arrangement that follows, is design, installation, inspection and testing by a competent person. Wiring a V2L output into the fixed installation (an inlet circuit, changeover or consumer-unit alteration) is normally notifiable under Part P (England; Wales, Scotland and NI differ).

**How compliance is demonstrated:** Open-PEN protective measure selected from the §722.411.4.1 list and its operation proven by test — including that it does not re-close onto the hazard; Initial verification to BS 7671 Part 6 with an Electrical Installation Certificate; RCD operation proven by test in both grid and V2L modes; For a TT route: earth-electrode resistance (Ra) measured low and stable enough for disconnection, with no metallic path bridging the PME and TT earth systems; The actual V2L adapter's neutral-earth behaviour confirmed on the bench before it is relied on

## FAQ

### Does §722.411.4.1 ban PME for EVs outright?

No. It says a PME earth must **not be relied on** for the EV **unless** one of a listed set of open-PEN protective measures is applied. Broadly, those measures either hold the installation's earth close to true earth or detect loss of the PEN and disconnect the supply; the exact list and its conditions live in the licensed standard and the IET CoP, and the competent designer selects and proves the measure.

### What is an 'open PEN' and why is it dangerous on PME?

On a PME (TN-C-S) supply, neutral and earth share one combined PEN conductor up to the cut-out. If that PEN breaks in the network, neutral current returns through the earthing and bonding system instead, lifting earthed metalwork — pipes, an EV's body — toward line voltage. The fault is in the network, not your installation, which is what makes it so dangerous: nothing local looks wrong.

### Why does an EV-charging rule shape how I earth a V2L home-backup setup?

Because borrowing the house's PME earth for the floating V2L output re-imports the very open-PEN hazard §722.411.4.1 is written to prevent. The rule is the reason the two standard responses exist: a TT electrode for a separate outbuilding, or an isolation transformer indoors so you keep the single PME/MET earth. It must be designed and proven by test by a competent person.

### Did BS 7671 Amendment 4:2026 change the EV PME rule?

**Yes — verified.** A4:2026 revised Section 722 for bidirectional charging (V2G/V2H/V2L): §722.411.4.1 now lists explicit open-PEN protective-measure routes with the former 'not reasonably practicable' exception removed, and §551.7.1(c) adds a bidirectional protective-device requirement. Confirmed against the consolidated BS 7671:2018+A4:2026 text by our competent-person review (2026-07-09).

### The IET CoP 'narrowed' the PME workaround — which indent was removed?

We treat this as an **inference**, not a precise indent claim. The 5th-edition CoP (Section 10) reflects a tightening of the PME open-PEN route, but the exact indent lettering of the §722.411.4.1 list is amendment-dependent and shifts between BS 7671 versions. Confirm the current indents against the licensed standard rather than relying on a specific letter.

---

_Author: Martin — qualified UK electrician (BEng Mech Eng; vehicle mechanic)._
_Last reviewed: 9 July 2026. Written against: BS 7671:2018 + A4:2026._
_Status: reviewed. General information, not project-specific design advice._
_[How we source this](/methodology) — evidence hierarchy, confidence flags and source policy._

## Sources

1. BS 7671:2018+A4:2026 — Requirements for Electrical Installations (IET/BSI) — https://electrical.theiet.org/bs-7671-18th-edition-wiring-regulations/about-bs-7671/ (§722, §722.411.4.1, §551.4.3.2.1 cited by clause only; standard text not reproduced)
2. IET — Amendment 4 updates to the 18th Edition — https://electrical.theiet.org/amendment-4-updates-to-18th-edition (publisher landing page — names no clause-level changes; the §722.411.4.1 position on this page is verified against the licensed A4:2026 text (competent-person check, 2026-07-09))
3. IET Code of Practice for EV Charging Equipment Installation, 5th Edition (2023) — Section 10 'Vehicle as Storage' — https://shop.theiet.org/code-of-practice-for-electric-vehicle-charging-equipment-installation-5th-edition (BS 7671:2018+A2:2022-aligned; cited by reference only)
4. IET — EV charging installations FAQs — https://electrical.theiet.org/bs-7671-18th-edition-wiring-regulations/faqs/electric-vehicle-charging-installations-faqs/
5. V2L Workshop standards reference (internal) — BS 7671 and IET CoP cards, with confidence flags
